I have to admit that I'm a very thin-skinned person. But even so, I'm still bothered by the number of innocuous things that some people claim to find offensive. This came to my mind a few days ago, when they were playing that Dixie Chicks song "I'm Not Ready To Make Nice" (or whatever it's called) at work, and I thought about that whole Toby Keith thing. Now, I'm no kind of Dixie Chicks fan, but it makes no sense that anyone, Bush supporter or not, would be bothered by someone saying that they're embarrassed to be from the same state as the President. I mean, that's not even really a political statement. [1] Then you hear about people getting mad at Whoopi Goldberg's "keep Bush out of my bush" jokes (which I'm sure weren't FUNNY, but I doubt they were particularly offensive either), and Conan O'Brien saying that Jon Stewart and Stephen Colbert "have done for fake news what the Fox News Channel has done for fake news." [2] I realize that some of this is probably political, and that, if the Bush administration and their media buddies can convince people that even a JOKING criticism is bad, they'll steer away from REAL criticism. But it's not only the Bush-backers who do this kind of thing. As much as I hate Ann Coulter, I think that the mainstream media tend to treat her in a profoundly stupid fashion. She'll make one of her over-the-top statements about how a leading Democrat is gay [3], or we need to wipe the Middle East off the map, or September 11 widows are enjoying their fame. Then she'll go on the media circuit, and the interviewers will say, in so many words, "Ann, you're so MEAN! Why can't you be NICE?" I'm certainly not defending Coulter, and it disturbs me to no end that there are people who actually take her crap seriously. But do the mainsteam media just not realize that causing offense is what she does, and the "You big meanie!" reaction is just what she wants?
Along with this comes to whole idea of the Forced Apology. It seems like people nowadays have gotten into the habit of demanding apologies. But if someone really IS sorry for what they said, won't they apologize on their own? A forced apology is likely to be a phony apology, and what good does that do? I believe Whoopi was forced to apologize for her jokes (and not because they were too obvious), and I've heard of that happening on other occasions that I can't recall at the moment. It's like we live in a society where no one actually understands the concept of apologizing.
[1] I think the Dixie Chicks later BECAME political, but that was kind of a self-fulfilling prophecy.
[2] DISCLAIMER: I didn't see either of these things first-hand, and the quote might be slightly off.
[3] As I've told
bethje, I don't even think her comment about John Edwards being a "fag" IS offensive. In order to be offensive, wouldn't it have to be based on something, and make some kind of sense? The "fag" comment was just utter nonsense.
Along with this comes to whole idea of the Forced Apology. It seems like people nowadays have gotten into the habit of demanding apologies. But if someone really IS sorry for what they said, won't they apologize on their own? A forced apology is likely to be a phony apology, and what good does that do? I believe Whoopi was forced to apologize for her jokes (and not because they were too obvious), and I've heard of that happening on other occasions that I can't recall at the moment. It's like we live in a society where no one actually understands the concept of apologizing.
[1] I think the Dixie Chicks later BECAME political, but that was kind of a self-fulfilling prophecy.
[2] DISCLAIMER: I didn't see either of these things first-hand, and the quote might be slightly off.
[3] As I've told