I'm preparing myself for the
Decemberists concert next Friday by listening to their albums. Based on hearing all three in a row, I think
Picaresque (the newest one) is my overall favorite, but the other two have some better individual songs. They also have more tracks that I find to be weaker or more forgettable than anything on
Picaresque.
On a related note, I've been thinking recently about what makes a good album. I guess a really good album is usually one where every song is good, and they all work well together. Of course, several excellent songs can sometimes make an album, and cause you to forget some not-so-hot tracks.
I've found that I often tend to like albums with a lot of songs. People will often employ the quality-over-quantity argument, and say that an album with a few really great songs is better than one with a lot of mediocre ones. I agree, of course, but my question is: Who's to say what's really great, or what's mediocre? One person's pointless filler could be another person's favorite track. Besides, I tend to be a completist, so I prefer that a song be released even if it isn't one of the band or artist's better numbers. That doesn't necessarily mean it has to be on an album, though. God gave us EP's and rarities collections for a reason.
I suppose it's best if you can get both quality AND quantity, which does happen on occasion. I like point out
They Might Be Giants'
John Henry (20 tracks) and
Frank Black's
Teenager of the Year (22 tracks) as examples of this. Sure, they both have songs that aren't quite as great as the others. The improvisational ending of "Spy" gets old quickly. I find that "Why Must I Be Sad?" drags somewhat. "Fazer Eyes" might be a bit on the weak side. But I wouldn't say any of these songs are truly BAD, or insist that they're filler. (Honestly, using the word "filler" to refer to a song on a long album strikes me as rather inappropriate anyway. Doesn't "filler" pretty much imply that the album would be too short without it? Some people seem to think that any short song is "filler," but that makes no sense to me.) Nor do I think there's anything wrong with the flow of either of these albums. I'm sure there are other long albums that could have benefitted from a few tracks being cut, but such is not always the case.
Speaking of albums, is anything else worth getting coming out this year? I remember hearing rumors about something new from
Neko Case, the two final
Fuzzy Warbles discs, and even a new
Cracker album, but I haven't heard anything recent to confirm that any of these rumors are true. Actually, I DO expect the FW discs to come out this year, but I have no idea when. And there's that TMBG
Venue Songs DVD that's coming out soon, but that's not really an album per se.
Meh, this entry has mostly just been stuff I've been thinking about. I mean, I guess all of them are like that to an extent, but usually there's something more concrete to them. I mean, people (no, don't ask me what people, because I'm not sure I know) say to just write what you're thinking about, but usually that's really boring. A lot of the time, I think in lists. Like, when I'm bored, I'll just mentally list characters or locations from Oz books, or my favorite song from each TMBG album, or something like that. Of course, I make posts like that occasionally, but I try not to overdo it. A general rule for lists is that they can be fun to write, but they're pretty boring to read.
One thing I have been thinking about that I actually might want to write down (although not here) is a sort of compilation of the histories of the various small kingdoms of Oz. There are a whole bunch of places in the Oz books that are full of unlikely beings, and often just seem to appear out of nowhere to bother the protagonists. When I read about them, I often find myself trying to come up with histories to explain how such unusual places could come to exist, and what life might be like when they're NOT being bothered by intruders who refuse to be like them. If I could come up with a bunch of descriptions of these places, it might make for an interesting document.
Finally, happy birthday to
obsessical. Welcome to adulthood! I hope you find it to be all it's cracked up to be.